Episode 38 – Many Lives, Many Origins Installment 1 – Superman: Birthright Part 1

This time out I’m starting a new series that will run irregularly through 2026 called Many Lives, Many Origins. Superman has one of the best origins in comics. It’s up there with Batman and Spider-Man as having a backstory that is timeless and just about perfect. Rocketed as a baby when his home world exploded, found by a kindly couple and raised as their son, Superman discovered that he possessed powers and abilities far beyond those of mortal men and decided to use those powers to help mankind. Those basic elements have been part of Superman’s backstory since his first appearance in Action Comics #1.

While those elements and that basic overview have been a constant in Superman’s life, the particulars of those elements have changed. Evolved in some cases, regressed in others. The names of his birth parents have undergone small changes. The names of the kindly couple that found him have changed. Is Krypton a pulp, science fiction wonderland full of rhondors and jewel mountains or is it a cold, sterile place that “deserved to be blown up”? Was Superman ever Superboy? Did he have his powers as a baby, or did they take years to develop? The differences are what I find fascinating, and I thought it would be fun to look at those origins, whether it’s in comics, in live action, in animation, in audio, or prose, and a do a deep dive into them.

To kick things off, I decided to look at Superman: Birthright. Published from July 2003 to July 2004 and written by Mark Waid with art by Leinil Francis Yu, this 12 issue maxi-series was supposed to be a new origin for a new age. I wasn’t the biggest fan of this series when it first came out, but over the years I’ve softened on it and this most recent re-read really opened my eyes to how good this retelling of Superman’s origin was, so I thought it would be a good way to kick this series off.

In this first part of a two part look at the series I go over what was going on with Superman in the comics when the series was published, Waid and Yu’s take on Krypton, the idea of Superman being a lonely character, how this version balances that loneliness with Clark’s desire to help people, Jonathan and Martha Kent, the new take on Lois, Superman’s grand reveal, his first confrontation with Lex in costume, and more. Or, more succinctly, I talk about the first five issues of the series.

Feedback for the show can be sent to itallcomesbacktosuperman@gmail.com. You can subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, iHeart Radio, Audible. This show is part of The Fortress of Baileytude Podcasting Network, which is on Patreon. This is a tip jar as I have no time for extra content at the moment, but if you like content I produce please consider contributing a dollar a month if you can.

The opening and closing theme is titled Journey and was composed by Pontus Rufelt. It is licensed from Shockwave-Sound.

Next time: I finish my analysis of Superman: Birthright. Spoiler warning…I really liked it.